Best Shoe Stretcher of 2019

  Comparison

Product Size Weight Price
Shoe Stretcher Men Shoe Stretcher Men 17.4 x 6.8 x 3.9 inches 2 pounds $
FootFitter Premium Professional 2-Way Shoe Stretcher FootFitter Premium Professional 2-Way Shoe Stretcher 15.8 x 5.1 x 4.1 inches 1.95 pounds $$
Shoe Stretcher 4-way Shoe Stretcher 4-way 16 x 3 x 2 inches 2.45 pounds $
XYH Shoe Stretcher for ladies boots XYH Shoe Stretcher for ladies boots 20 x 6 x 3 inches 2.15 pounds $$
YUKIK Shoe Stretcher with 3 High Heel Protectors YUKIK Shoe Stretcher with 3 High Heel Protectors 14.6 x 4.7 x 2.4 inches 2.28 pounds $

Buying new shoes is something that simply makes people happier, regardless of their gender and preferences. However, almost without exception, wearing new shoes for the first time and even the next few ones, is extremely uncomfortable. The fact that new shoes hurt your feet all the time doesn’t mean that they are made of poor quality materials. It simply means that your feet aren’t the exact same shape and size as the shoes. Your feet might be right in between two sizes, for instance. Especially when it comes to leather shoes, you shouldn’t be fooled by the first-time discomfort. We all know that leather stretches after wearing it once or twice. But if you know all that and still think about it with terror, then you should begin to use shoe stretchers.

Shoe stretchers are extremely practical accessories that make shoes more comfortable. They are ideal for suede and leather shoes, but can be used with other natural materials, too. What is even more interesting is that shoe stretchers can expand the material a little bit, so that if the shoe is too tight, it becomes the right size in no time.

If you are looking to buy some of the best shoe stretchers on the market, you are probably wondering which model is worth your money. There are a lot of different options on the market that you can choose from. Some shoe stretchers are made for flats, others for boots and others for high heels. So, first of all, it is important to decide which types of shoes you wish to stretch. If you already know that, then you are in the right place. This article will show you what the most popular products on the market are right now.

We have selected 5 of the best-selling shoe stretchers, analyzed their features and characteristics and highlighted their pros and cons based on personal observations and consumer feedback. Check them out below:  

1 Shoe Stretcher Men

When thinking about shoe stretchers, you probably think about that classic wooden model that you saw in your parents’ house during childhood. Modern manufacturers understand the importance of durability, but some of them preferred to use other, lighter materials when building these accessories, while keeping the same efficiency level. It is this model’s case from Lanney that is made of ABS plastic. It is a pair of shoe stretchers that also includes other accessories such as: 12 bunion plugs, 3 heighten pads, a shoe horn and a drawstring carrying bag. To ensure that you will be able to use these stretchers correctly, the manufacturer has also included easy instructions.

Although this model is made of ABS plastic, it also has heavy-duty metal components, such as the shaft and screws. The only case in which that could make them less durable than wooden stretchers is if someone intentionally wants to break them; as we all know, no matter how strong plastic is, can break easier than wood. Having a great shape and design, this product is easy to use and is capable of widening and lengthening the shoe. It comes with a wheel knob that allows you to move the heel block forwards or backwards. The shoe vamp can be adjusted with the help of the included heightening pads, while the bunion plugs are very useful is you want to stretch only specific areas of the shoe’s sides.

What’s to like?

  • It is made of ABS plastic
  • It is affordable
  • It is highly adjustable
  • It is nicely designed
  • It is easy to use
  • It has heavy-duty metal shaft and screws
  • It is sturdy
  • It is rustproof
  • It has a 4-way adjustment design
  • It has a metal knob
  • It can be used for flat shoes, boots and wedge heels
  • It includes 12 bunion plugs
  • It includes 3 heighten pads
  • It comes with a carrying bag

What’s not to like?

  • It doesn’t work for pumps

2 FootFitter Premium Professional 2-Way Shoe Stretcher

If you work in a professional shoe workshop or you simply have an impressive number of high-quality, expensive shoes, then you should definitely buy a premium stretcher. This product is used by professionals, as well and in households. Although this is a single shoe stretcher, it is totally worth the money. It is made of durable, treated wood, it has metal mechanics made from stainless steel, a toe block crafted from German beech wood and it is shaped to fit both the left and right shoe. Its huge advantage is that it comes with 16 plug holes that allow you to place stretching plugs wherever your pressure points are.

Thanks to widening handle, you can turn open or close the toe block that widens the tip of the shoe. Also, it has a strong lengthening wheel that allows you to move the heel block that stretches the length of the shoe. This product can be used for both men’s and women’s shoes. It is suitable for sizes between 6.5 and 16 for men’s shoes and 3.5 to 12 for women’s shoes. It is a premium product that will last a lifetime. It measures 15.8 x 5.1 x 4.1 inches and it weighs 1.95 pounds. Thanks to its small size, you can store it wherever you want when not in use. However, no matter how effective this product is, it won’t work on shoes made of materials that don’t stretch, such as hiking shoes.

What’s to like?

  • It is a premium product
  • It can be used by professionals
  • It is a 2-way stretcher
  • It is suitable for both left and right shoes
  • It is made of beech wood
  • It is extremely durable
  • It has 16 holes for customizable spot relief
  • It has metal mechanics
  • Its hoes are suitable for corns and bunions
  • It fits all regular sizes
  • It can be stored anywhere

What’s not to like?

  • It is a single shoe stretcher, doesn’t come in a pair

3 Shoe Stretcher 4-way

If you are looking for an inexpensive pair of stretchers, then this is probably the product that will draw your attention first. It has a great price, it comes in pink and yellow, it is durable and smooth and it is capable of expanding the shoes in 4 directions. This product was designed for women, so you might be interested in buying it if you have rather small-sized shoes. Although it is available in 3 sizes, this particular model was designed to stretch shoes between 5.5 and 10 (US size). It is made of polyurethane plastic and has a steel shaft. Its construction is mostly from plastic due to environmental concerns, but it is almost as durable as wooden stretchers. This kit includes 2 shoe stretchers, for the right and left foot, 8 bunion plugs and 2 heightening pads.

This product is extremely easy to use. You simply have to insert it in the shoe, with the black piece facing downwards. To stretch the width, you have to rotate the handle clockwise. If you want to stretch the length, you must move the heel block closer to the heel and rotate the knob in clockwise direction. If you have pressure points that you are well aware of, you must detect the plug holes in those spots, place the bunion plugs in those holes and simply insert the stretcher inside the shoe. The instructions that this pair includes are easy to understand, so you will not have any issues figuring out how to use the product. Just like the previous 2 products, this pair is easy to store whenever not in use. Each stretcher measures 16 x 3 x 2 inches. The total weight of the pair is 2.45 pounds.

What’s to like?

  • It is inexpensive
  • It has a durable design
  • It is made of Polyurethane plastic
  • It comes with a steel shaft
  • Its metal and plastic parts don’t get deformed or corroded
  • It is a 4-way adjustable stretcher
  • It includes 8 bunion plugs
  • It has 2 high pads
  • It is easy to use
  • It includes comprehensible instructions
  • It includes a drawstring bag
  • It comes in pink and yellow

What’s not to like?

  • It is designed for women’s shoes only

4 XYH Shoe Stretcher for ladies boots

Do you own great-looking boots that kill your feet? By comparison to the previous products in our list, this product was designed to stretch higher shoes, such as winter boots that cover your entire calf. Although it comes in pink, it can be used to expand both men’s and women’s boots, between the following sizes: 3.5 – 11.5 for women’s boots and 5 – 16 for men’s boots. It is made of plastic, it has long shafts that makes it a lot easier to insert the stretcher inside the shoe and accessories that allow you to release pressure points from newly bought boots, or thick ones that take longer to stretch.

This kit includes a spot stretching plug for corns and bunions, a toe block that easily stretcher the width of the shoe and has 3 holes on each side. It is a 2-way stretcher that has a heart shaped shaft, which you will love if you like unconventional designs. This is an adjustable product. To adjust the length you simply have to rotate the knob clockwise. If you want to adjust the width, you have to rotate the hook clockwise. Removing the stretchers is a breeze. You simply have to turn the handles counter clockwise. It has a great price, slightly lower than the other products in this list. You will need a bit of extra space to store them when not used, as they measure 20 x 6 x 3 inches.

What’s to like?

  • It is inexpensive
  • It is nicely designed
  • It comes in pink
  • It is suitable for both men’s and women’s boots
  • It has an extra-long shaft
  • Its shaft is heart shaped
  • It is adjustable
  • It comes with 12 holes for bunion plugs
  • It includes bunion plugs
  • It is made of durable plastic
  • It is smooth

What’s not to like?

  • The toe box is a bit too short for pumps or boots with narrower tips
  • It isn’t a 4-way stretcher

5 YUKIK Shoe Stretcher with 3 High Heel Protectors

At first glance, this pair of shoe stretchers looks very similar to product number 4, but if you look closer, it is quite different. It is a product that is made from polyurethane plastic; it is adjustable and capable of stretching both the width and the length of high boots. There’s nothing different so far about them. The main difference consists of the design of the product that has a rotating wheel attached to the heart-shaped shaft. It has a longer internal structure, a stainless steel handle and widens the toe box just enough to do the job it is built for. It included bunion plugs for the pressure points and has 3 pairs of high heel protectors.

This kit includes a canvas pocket, 2 high heel shoe stretchers, 2 pad high plugs, 6 high heel protectors, as well as 8 bunion plugs. In order to widen the shoe, you must rotate the knob clockwise. If you want to lengthen the shoe, you simply have to rotate the black wheel until the desired point. It is recommended to leave the stretcher inside the shoe for approximately 48 hours in order to obtain optimal results, but in some cases, 24 hours are just enough, too. It all depends on the thickness and elasticity of the material. Unlike other shoe stretchers, this model is also suitable for pumps. It can be used by both men and women, as it is suitable for all sizes.

What’s to like?

  • It is affordable
  • It has an ergonomic design
  • It is made of tough plastic and stainless steel
  • It is suitable for both men’s and women’s shoes
  • It fits all shoe sizes
  • It has a nice internal structure
  • It comes with bunion plugs
  • It has a good widening stretch
  • It has a long handle
  • It has high heel protectors
  • It has heel stretchers
  • It is compatible with pumps

What’s not to like?

  • It is a bit bulky

Do shoe stretchers help with bunions?

If you have bunions, then you know how painful it can be to walk in tight shoes. It isn’t only uncomfortable, but it can also hurt your feet more than you can imagine, by deforming them completely. Choosing wide shoes is one of the best options in this case, but sometimes you have no choice but to walk into those new shoes that you just bought. It becomes even more difficult if you are a woman and you really need to wear heels. Before despairing, you should know that shoe stretchers can be of real help, especially if you use them regularly. Although they are known for their ability to stretch all types of shoes, more or less, they work best on those that are made of leather or suede.

When using a shoe stretcher, you basically stretch the material just as much as you need, so the shoe will not become too loose. This will definitely help you control the discomfort on the long-term, which why everyone who has bunions should use them.  

Should you choose wooden or plastic shoe stretchers?

Both wooden and plastic shoe trees are effective, but the main differences between them consist of the price and durability. While plastic models are much more inexpensive, they are also less durable. Unlike wooden stretchers, they break more easily. Especially cedar shoe stretchers are known for their durability, sturdiness and ability to eliminate unpleasant odors from shoes. Another great advantage of wooden models is that they can absorb moisture and help prolong the life of leather or suede shoes. Other than this, both plastic and wooden stretchers can be equally efficient. You can find models that are adjustable and easy to use from both materials. No matter what you choose or if the material is important for you or not, you should know that these accessories can help you stretch the shoes up to 3 inches wider.

What should you use? Shoe stretcher vs. shoe tree

Most people think that they need to choose between using shoe stretchers or shoe trees, but the truth is that they serve different purposes. Both accessories can be used at different moments. While shoe trees are designed to maintain the size and shape of the shoe, to avoid wrinkles from forming and preserving the beautiful aspect of the material, shoe stretchers are only recommended for use when you want to stretch them, make them a bit wider. It is true that a stretcher can also be used as a tree, as it can be set to a size that doesn’t necessary stretch the leather, but it isn’t as comfortable to use, due to the metal extension it is equipped with. If you want to use shoe stretchers as trees for a while, you can do so without worries. Except for the comfort factor that it somehow lacks, such a product is capable of even absorbing moisture from the shoes, just like their opponents.

When buying a shoe stretcher, there are a few things that you should consider besides the type of shoes that you will be using it on. For instance, the size range is extremely important and you really need to keep this in mind or else, it will be useless. Also, see if you need a basic stretcher or you need a two-way one, which expands both length and width. Also, there is always a risk of overstretching leather shoes, so make sure that you read the instructions thoroughly. Also, keep in mind that there are shoe stretcher sprays and creams that you can use together with this accessory, in order to speed up the process and soften the leather.

The 5 products in our list are high-quality shoe stretchers that come with clear instructions. They are made of durable materials and make the best accessory for premium shoes that need protection and a little stretching. By protecting your feet, you protect yourself and get to improve your mood, so if you think that buying good shoe stretchers isn’t important, then you should think again.


Rate this article:

...